Race for Maine Senate District 4

in the 2016 General Election

Carole J. Boothroyd

Carole J. Boothroyd

4,892 (27.4%)

Democratic - Dover-Foxcroft

Candidate profile

Paul T. Davis Sr.

Paul T. Davis Sr.

12,960 (72.6%)

Republican - Sangerville

Candidate profile

Is Maine too generous in providing social services to its residents? Which government benefits should be increased or decreased?

Boothroyd
Maine probably needs better oversight of its social services and less exemptions from the work requirement for TANF. Maine needs to bring its public health system up to standard.

Show full answers

Davis
We need to evaluate all federal,state,and local benefit programs to make sure money is being spent correctly and to eliminate overlapping. If possible after this evaluation services could be offered to the thousands of severely handicapped people on waiting lists. Some waiting for years for services.

Show full answers

Do you support expanding or raising the sales tax to lower the state income tax? Why or why not?

Boothroyd
No I don't support expanding the sales tax in order to cut income taxes at this time. I support increasing state revenues by creating more small businesses and jobs in Maine. In addition, I think the income tax is a more reliable source of revenue than sales taxes.

Show full answers

Davis
Yes. Everyone pays sales tax. I am however, very cautious as to how it is expanded. Basic necessities of life should not be taxed. Our spending needs to be brought under control.We spend far to much money. The income tax is a job killer.

Show full answers

Do you support marijuana legalization in Maine, as outlined in Question 1?

Boothroyd
Yes

Show full answers

Please explain your answer. (Not required)

Boothroyd
I see no reason for marijuana to be illegal or for police to spend their valuable time arresting marijuana users. Alcohol is legal, yet it poses a much greater risk of addiction, which harms individuals, families and communities. The experiment to outlaw alcohol in the USA failed: the experiment to outlaw cannabis should also fail.

Show full answers

Davis
As a former police officer am very concerned about marijuana related traffic deaths. There is not any way to test for the level of the drug in the blood.

Show full answers

Do you support raising taxes on Mainers with incomes above $200,000 to increase state aid to education, as outlined in Question 2?

Boothroyd
Yes

Show full answers

Please explain your answer. (Not required)

Boothroyd
Until the state meets its obligation to fund schools at the 55% approved by voters in 2004, some measure is needed to keep our public schools from failing.

Show full answers

Davis
Maine will have the 2nd highest income tax rate in the U.S. behind only California if this passes. We have a huge shortage proffsionals working in Maine. We need doctors, nurses, engineers etc. This will cause them not to come here and for others to leave.

Show full answers

Do you support universal background checks for firearm sales, as outlined in Question 3?

Boothroyd
Yes

Show full answers

Please explain your answer. (Not required)

Boothroyd
I am willing to support the endorsement of the Maine Police Chiefs.

Show full answers

Davis
Maine does not have a gun problem.

Show full answers

Should Maine raise its minimum wage, as outlined in Question 4?

Boothroyd
Yes

Show full answers

Please explain your answer. (Not required.)

Boothroyd
Many of our small businesses are already paying above minimum wages because they value their employees and want them to stay. When companies don't pay a living wage, it is often the taxpayers who end up subsidizing their employees with food stamps or other benefits.

Show full answers

Davis
Small business will suffer. Inflation will greatly increase. This will hurt retirees. Restaurants will have a very difficult time to stay in business.

Show full answers

Do you support the initiative to use ranked-choice voting to elect state and federal officials in Maine, as outlined in Question 5?

Boothroyd
Yes

Show full answers

Please explain your answer. (Not required)

Boothroyd
Ranked-choice voting will insure that a winning candidate has a majority of votes

Show full answers

Davis
Far to confusing. I would,support a runoff between top two votergetters. Also this is unconstitutional, according to the Attorney General.

Show full answers

Should Maine prioritize law enforcement efforts to intercept drug traffickers over expanding access to substance abuse treatment, such those that incorporates medications like methadone and Suboxone?

Boothroyd
No, Maine needs a balanced approach to our drug and alcohol abuse epidemic.Law enforcement can step up efforts to stop drug traffickers, but that approach alone will not be effective in reducing the opiate crisis. I believe addiction requires intensive medical intervention and addicts in Maine have very limited access to such treatment. This is especially true for pregnant women and mothers.

Show full answers

Davis
Yes. Drug enforcement need to be a priority.

Show full answers

Should Maines constitutional officers -- the secretary of state, the attorney general, auditor and the treasurer -- continue to be elected by the Legislature or by statewide popular vote?

Boothroyd
Continue to be elected by the Legislature

Show full answers

Davis
Yes I support direct election.

Show full answers

Is the size of Maines Legislature appropriate? Should the pay for legislative service be increased?

Boothroyd
I think the size of the House is appropriate, but Senate Districts can be extremely large geographic areas and may require two senators per district. If we want a more representative sample of Mainers in the legislature, the pay should be increased to the average salary in Maine.

Show full answers

Davis
Yes. Increasing size will only result in larger staff.

Show full answers

Would you support sanctioning another elected official if he or she made public comments or statements that were considered racist, offensive or prejudicial?

Boothroyd
Yes

Show full answers

Davis
No. Public opinion will do that.

Show full answers

Would you support a so-called right to work law in Maine?

Boothroyd
No

Show full answers

Davis
Yes. States that have right to work laws are far better off than those that don't.

Show full answers

Would you support legislation or a ballot question to allow more casinos in Maine?

Boothroyd
Yes

Show full answers

Davis
We have enough gambling now.

Show full answers

What is the biggest barrier to economic development in Maine and what can the Legislature do to address it?

Boothroyd
I don't know what the biggest barrier to economic development is, but I can name a few that are very important. One, the workforce in Maine is under-trained and under-educated, in part because post-high school education is too expensive for many families. The legislature can address the problem by giving more funding to higher education institutions. Currently, Maine invests only 4% of its budget in higher education. Two, the state is fairly lavish with corporate tax exemptions, but doesn't do enough to support small businesses. The legislature could cut back on subsidies to large corporations and increase them for small business. Three, looking backward to past industries rather than anticipating future needs is holding Maine back from growing a robust economy. Legislation needs to embrace new technologies. An example is the solar bill which was vetoed by the governor and failed to override his veto. Renewable sources of energy are the wave of the future and represent a huge growth area for the economy.

Show full answers

Davis
High taxes. High energy costs and over regulation.

Show full answers

Census data show Maines population is aging and decreasing, with some economists suggesting that immigration is the best way to reverse those trends. What should the state do to address this demographic trend?

Boothroyd
The state should welcome legal immigrants and work to increase small businesses, the backbone of Maine's economy. More young people will stay in Maine or move to Maine if they can make a decent living here.

Show full answers

Davis
Increase business climate, make it profitable for businesses to locate in Maine. Economic opportunity will bring young people to Maine.

Show full answers

What is the most pressing issue in Maine these questions have not addressed?

Boothroyd
Climate change and its effect on the future of Maine's marine, agricultural and tourism industries.

Show full answers

Davis
The lack of economic opportunity is the biggest problem Maine has.

Show full answers